Feedback

Five colourful faces show different emotional responses, from anger and sadness to neutral, pleased and happy.

Feedback is one of the most useful tools we have for understanding ourselves and improving the way we communicate.

“We all need people who will give us feedback. That’s how we improve.” — Bill Gates

“Feedback is the breakfast of champions.” — Rick Tate (often shared by Ken Blanchard)

“Criticism, like rain, should be gentle enough to nourish a man’s growth without destroying his roots.” — Frank A. Clark

“I don’t believe that receiving feedback well means that you have to take the feedback.” — Sheila Heen

“Make feedback normal. Not a performance review.” — Ed Batista

But there is something important to remember about feedback:

ADVERTISEMENT
200 × 100
small in-text unit 3
A man tests bath water with his hand while adjusting the tap in response to its temperature.

Feedback is somebody else’s view. It may be true for you. It may not be true for you. And sometimes it may not even be completely true for the person giving it. That sounds complicated — and it is. But understanding this is the key to making feedback useful rather than allowing it to control you.

What is feedback? Feedback is someone’s version of what they see, hear or experience. That makes it valuable because other people can see things about us that we don’t see ourselves. But it also means we should be careful about treating feedback as fact. If someone says, "You are not making sense," they are telling you how your communication worked for them.

That is different from saying that you objectively make no sense. The distinction matters. One person may misunderstand you. Another person may understand you perfectly. The feedback tells you something about the communication, but it doesn’t necessarily tell you everything about yourself.

Own your feedback. Give feedback from your own experience

There is a simple way to make feedback more useful. Instead of telling somebody what they are, tell them what you experienced. For example, instead of saying "You are not making sense," you could say "I didn’t understand what you said." Instead of saying "Your behaviour is annoying me," try "I am feeling uncomfortable."

Instead of saying "You are late," you might say "Can you be on time next time?" The difference is subtle but powerful. You are no longer claiming to know what is true for another person. You are owning what is true for you. And this applies to positive feedback too.

Instead of telling someone "You are terrific," you might simply say "I love it." You are telling them what you experienced rather than defining who they are.

ADVERTISEMENT
200 × 100
small in-text unit 1

Receiving feedback

Receiving feedback can be much harder than giving it. When somebody tells us something about ourselves that we don’t like, our first reaction may be to defend ourselves.

Knowing yourself can help you decide whether feedback contains something useful, and avoid taking the bait of a personal attack. If someone calls you stupid, you might calmly say, “Thank you. I didn’t realise you felt that way.” You can consider what they said without treating it as a verdict about you.

We may think:

"That’s not true." "They don’t understand me." "Who are they to tell me that?" Perhaps they’re right. Perhaps they’re wrong.

But before rejecting the feedback, there is another possibility:

What if there is something useful in it? Feedback doesn’t have to be accepted as truth to be useful. You can listen to it, consider it and decide what — if anything — you want to do with it.

One person's feedback is one person's view

The Johari Window with a right-pointing feedback arrow and upward share arrow, showing open, blind, hidden and unknown areas.

In my workshops, I make this very clear. One person’s feedback is simply one person’s view. If two people give you similar feedback, it becomes more interesting. If three or more people independently tell you the same thing, it may be worth investigating seriously.

That still doesn’t automatically make it true. People can share the same misunderstanding. But repeated feedback gives you information that is difficult to ignore.

One of the questions I suggest asking yourself is:

"Do I want people to experience me this way?" If the answer is no, you have a choice. You can investigate it. You can change something. You can ask somebody you trust for their opinion.

Or you can decide that the feedback isn’t relevant to you. The important thing is that you make the decision rather than simply reacting to the feedback.

What I’ve learned from my workshops

For more than 20 years I have used feedback extensively in my workshops.

Participants are encouraged to give feedback to one another — what works for them and what doesn’t. I’ve also spent a lot of time helping people understand how to give feedback in a way that is easier for another person to hear.

It isn’t always successful. In fact, much of the feedback I have seen has been poorly phrased. People often struggle to describe what they actually observed or experienced. Some feedback is negative.

Some is positive. And some is neither particularly useful nor particularly clear. That’s why how you give feedback matters. But even when feedback is carefully given, you still cannot control how the other person receives it.

A woman shares a thoughtful observation in a workshop while an older man and another participant listen.

A simple piece of feedback can change someone’s life One of the most interesting things about feedback is that you never really know what impact it will have. On one workshop, a participant discovered from the other participants that they had difficulty smiling. At the end of the workshop, they shared this with everyone — with a huge smile on their face. Three months later they contacted me and told me that smiling had become a habit and that their world had changed for the better.

A very simple piece of feedback had produced a significant change. That’s the potential of good feedback. A lesson from a communication game I developed a game for one of my workshops to encourage communication and listening. Participants answer questions while the other players assess their communication. At the end, everybody gives feedback to the other participants.

It produces some fascinating results. People often begin by listening carefully. Then, as the game develops, they become more animated. They start talking over each other, laughing and forgetting that the exercise is supposed to be about listening. Their scores can also reveal surprising differences between how people see themselves and how other people experience them.

On one occasion, a participant consistently gave himself very high scores while giving considerably lower scores to everyone else. I gave him the feedback. He received it well. When the game was played again, his scoring changed considerably and became much more aligned with the other participants and my observations. That was feedback doing exactly what it should do: giving somebody information they could use.

You cannot always make people hear you One of the lessons I’ve learned through many years of running workshops is that you can explain something perfectly and still not know how somebody will hear it. My workshops are deliberately experiential. There are no lectures. Participants learn from the experiences they have with one another and from the observations I make as the facilitator.

I explain this carefully before the workshop begins. And yet, occasionally somebody will still write in their evaluation that they wanted more lectures!

It makes me smile because it demonstrates the very thing I’m teaching:

We cannot control what another person hears from our communication. We can do everything we can to communicate clearly. But ultimately, the other person decides what they hear and how they interpret it.

Feedback from an audience

A presenter notices audience members’ expressions and adapts her explanation.

The same principle applies when speaking to an audience. A good speaker watches the audience. Are they engaged? Are they looking interested? Are they becoming distracted?

Are they responding to what is being said? The audience is giving the speaker feedback all the time. A speaker who ignores that feedback can lose the audience. A speaker who notices it can adjust and reconnect. I’ve found this particularly important when speaking because the audience rarely tells you directly what is happening.

You have to listen with your eyes as well as your ears. Don’t tell people what they should do I often get people at golf telling me what I should be doing. The problem is that they don’t necessarily know what will work for me. They may see something in my swing and have a perfectly reasonable suggestion, but there can be many different ways of solving the same problem.

The same applies to life and communication. You can tell someone what you see. You can tell them what your experience has been. But be careful about telling somebody what they should do.

You don’t know everything about them, their circumstances or what will work for them. Even when you have good intentions, advice can easily become an instruction. And that’s something I have had to learn myself because I genuinely like helping people.

Feedback is everywhere

We receive feedback constantly. Our eyes, ears, thoughts, feelings and experiences are giving us information all the time. We couldn’t possibly consciously process all of it, so our brains filter an enormous amount automatically. But if you want to change something about yourself or the way you communicate, it helps to become more attentive to useful feedback. First, notice it.

Then you have to decide what to do with it. So what do you do with negative feedback? Don’t automatically reject it. Don’t automatically accept it either. Investigate it.

Ask yourself:

ADVERTISEMENT
200 × 100
small in-text unit 4
  • Is there something here that I can learn?
  • Have other people said something similar?
  • Is this how I want people to experience me?
  • What would happen if I changed something?
  • Do I need more information before deciding?
A man reviews feedback in a notebook and groups blank cards into recurring themes.

You can even write feedback down and look for patterns over time. If the same message keeps appearing, it may be worth paying particular attention to it. And if the feedback is positive but you find yourself rejecting it, that is worth examining too. Sometimes we are much more comfortable accepting criticism than accepting praise. Learning to recognise how other people genuinely experience you can be an important part of understanding yourself.

Feedback is free. It costs nothing. And when it is genuine, it can be incredibly valuable. The trick is learning how to give it honestly, receive it openly and decide intelligently what to do with it. You don’t have to agree with every piece of feedback you receive. You don’t have to change every time somebody criticises you.

But you should give yourself the opportunity to learn from what other people are telling you. And when somebody gives you feedback, even if you don’t agree with it, a simple response can be: "Thank you. I’ll think about that." You can then decide what happens next.

The important thing to remember

Feedback is information, not a verdict. It tells you how something looks, sounds or feels to somebody else. Listen to it. Own the feedback you give. Consider carefully the feedback you receive.

And then make your own decision about what, if anything, you want to change. That is how feedback becomes a tool for learning rather than a source of conflict.

IN-CONTENT ADVERTISEMENT
320 × 100 banner 1
Google AdSense unit will go here
IN-CONTENT ADVERTISEMENT
320 × 100 banner 2
Google AdSense unit will go here

Further Reading

Books Worth Exploring: Browse Lance’s recommended reading on communication, self-understanding, personal growth and leadership.

Related Articles

You may also find these articles useful:

ADVERTISEMENT PREVIEW
300 × 250 space
Google AdSense unit will go here